 |
|
|
Massachusetts Lemon Law Statutes
Chapter
90: Section 7N. Voiding contracts of sale.
Section
7N.
Notwithstanding any disclaimer of warranty, a motor vehicle
contract of sale may be voided by the buyer if the motor
vehicle fails to pass, within seven days from the date of
such sale, the periodic staggered inspection at an inspection
station licensed pursuant to section seven W; provided, that
the defects which are the reasons for the failure to issue
a certificate of inspection were not caused by the abusive
or negligent operation of the motor vehicle or by damage
resulting from an accident or collision occurring after the
date of the sale; and provided, further, that the cost of
repairs necessary to permit the issuance of a certificate
of inspection exceeds ten per cent of the purchase price
of the motor vehicle.
In
order to void a motor vehicle sale under this section the
buyer shall, within fourteen days from the date of sale,
notify the seller of his intention to do so, deliver the
motor vehicle to the seller, provide the seller with a written
statement signed by an authorized agent of such inspection
station stating the reasons why the motor vehicle failed
to pass the safety or combined safety and emissions inspection
and an estimate of the cost of necessary repairs. The buyer
shall be entitled to a refund of his purchase price unless
the buyer and seller agree in writing that the seller may
make the necessary repairs at his own cost and expense within
a reasonable period of time thereafter. This section shall
apply only to motor vehicles purchased for the immediate
personal or family use of the buyer.
Chapter
90: Section 7N.25.
Express warranty by dealer of used motor
vehicle; issuance; consumer's rights and remedies.
Section
7N?.
- For the purposes of this section the following words
shall have the following meanings:--
"Business
day", Monday to Friday, inclusive, except for state
or federal holidays.
"Consumer",
a buyer, other than for purposes of resale, of a motor vehicle,
any person to whom such motor vehicle is transferred during
the period of any express or statutory warranty under this
section applicable to such motor vehicle, and any other person
entitled by the terms of such warranty to enforce its obligations.
"Dealer",
any person engaged in the business of selling, offering for
sale, or negotiating the retail sale of used motor vehicles
or selling motor vehicles as broker or agent for another,
including the officers, agents and employees of such person
and any combination or association of dealers, but not including
a bank or other financial institution, or the commonwealth,
its agencies, bureaus, boards, commissions, authorities,
nor any of its political subdivisions. A person shall be
deemed to be engaged in the business of selling used motor
vehicles if such person has sold more than three used motor
vehicles in the preceding twelve months.
"Motor
vehicle" or "vehicle", any motor vehicle as
defined in section one, sold or replaced by a dealer or manufacturer,
except that it shall not include auto homes, vehicles built
primarily for off-road use or any vehicle used primarily
for business purposes.
"Private
seller", any person who is not a dealer and who offers
to sell or sells a used motor vehicle to a consumer.
"Purchase
price", the total of all payments made for the purchase
of a vehicle, including but not limited to any finance charges,
registration fees, payments made for credit life, accident,
health, and damage insurance, and collision and related comprehensive
insurance coverages and service contracts and the value of
a trade-in.
"Repurchase
price", the purchase price, as defined above, less any
cash award that was made by the dealer in an attempt to resolve
the dispute and was accepted by the consumer, and less any
refunds or rebates to which the consumer is entitled, plus
any incidental damages not previously reimbursed, including
but not limited to the reasonable costs of towing from point
of breakdown up to thirty miles to obtain required repairs
or to return the vehicle under this section, and the reasonable
costs of obtaining alternative transportation during the
applicable warranty period after the second day following
each such breakdown not to exceed fifteen dollars vehicle
rental charges for each day in which the cost of such alternative
transportation is reimbursable.
"Used
motor vehicle" or "used vehicle", any vehicle
driven more than the limited use necessary in moving or road
testing a new vehicle prior to delivery to a consumer, including
a demonstrator vehicle, except that it shall not include
auto homes, vehicles built primarily for off road use, motorcycles,
or any vehicle used primarily for business purposes.
-
- No used motor vehicle shall be sold in the commonwealth
by a dealer to a consumer unless accompanied by an express
written warranty covering the full cost of both parts and
labor necessary to repair any defect that impairs the said
used motor vehicle's safety or use; provided, however, that
the consumer may be required to pay no more than one hundred
dollars total toward the repair of any covered defect, series
of defects or combination of defects during the warranty
period. Defects that affect only appearance shall not be
deemed to impair safety or use for the purposes of this section.
For the purposes of this section, defect shall include defect,
malfunction or any combination or defects or malfunctions.
-
Defects or malfunctions which involve parts or components
that are covered or are warranted under an express warranty
issued by the dealer of the used motor vehicle shall be excluded
from this section if the following conditions have been met:
the manufacturer's warranty has been duly assigned or transferred
to the buyer; is enforceable according to its terms; is not
inconsistent with this section; and, the seller has assured
that the repair authorized by such manufacturer's express
warranty was made.
The
terms of the seller's warranty shall be tolled for any period
of time the used motor vehicle is out of service by reason
of repair under the manufacturer's warranty.
-
The express warranties required by this section shall be
of the following durations:
-
For a used motor vehicle which, at the time of sale, has
been operated less than forty thousand miles, ninety days
or three thousand seven hundred and fifty miles, whichever
occurs first. Said ninety days or three thousand seven hundred
and fifty mile warranty is in addition to any right the consumer
may have under section seven N?.
-
For a used motor vehicle which, at the time of sale, has
been operated forty thousand miles or more, but less than
eighty thousand miles, sixty days or two thousand five hundred
miles, whichever first occur.
-
For a used motor vehicle which, at the time of sale, has
been operated eighty thousand miles or more, but less than
one hundred and twenty-five thousand miles, thirty days or
one thousand two hundred and fifty miles, whichever first
occur.
-
If the used motor vehicle's true mileage is not known, such
warranty period shall be determined by the age of said used
motor vehicle in the following manner: a used motor vehicle
three years old or less shall have a warranty as provided
in clause (i); a used motor vehicle more than three, but
less than six years old, shall have a warranty as provided
in clause (ii); and a used motor vehicle six years old or
more shall have a warranty as provided in clause (iii). A
used motor vehicle's age shall be determined by subtracting
its model year from the year in which the warranty holder
purchased said used vehicle.
-
The warranty periods established by this section shall be
tolled during any period in which the used motor vehicle
is out of service as a result of any repair attempt pursuant
to any warranty created by this section. The applicable warranty
period shall be extended thirty days from the date of completion
of any repair required by this section as to the defect repaired
if the warranty would otherwise have expired during such
period.
- A dealer may repair, within the meaning of this section,
either by performing the repair himself or by arranging and
making payment for prompt repair by another.
-
A consumer shall return a vehicle for repair under this section
by presenting it to the dealer no later than five business
days after the expiration of the applicable warranty period
and informing him of the defect. Said return period shall
be tolled during any time period in which the consumer has
notified the dealer of the defect but cannot reasonably present
the vehicle to the dealer; including, but not limited to,
the reason that a used motor vehicle is inoperable and the
dealer refuses to pay the charge to tow said vehicle. The
dealer shall immediately accept return of a vehicle when
it is so presented. Said used motor vehicle shall be deemed
out of service commencing the day it is so presented, notwithstanding
any dealer's failure to accept its return on said day. During
the applicable warranty period and the aforesaid return period,
the dealer shall pay the reasonable costs of towing from
point of breakdown up to thirty miles to obtain required
repairs or to return the vehicle to the dealer.
Upon
return of the used motor vehicle to the consumer after repair,
the dealer shall provide the consumer with a warranty repair
receipt describing
- the defect complained of,
- the
work performed in an attempt to correct such defect and the
identity of the repairer if it is not the dealer, and
-
the parts replaced in performing such work. For the dealer
to toll the ten business day period as provided in clause
(ii) of this paragraph said dealer shall attach to each such
warranty repair receipt copies of such order forms, invoices,
receipts or other evidence of a parts order and its receipt
to evidence his compliance with this paragraph.
-
If the dealer fails to repair the same defect within three
attempts, or if the used motor vehicle is out of service
for more than a cumulative total of ten business days after
the consumer has returned it to the dealer for repair of
the same, then the dealer shall accept return of the vehicle
from the consumer and refund the full repurchase price, less
a reasonable allowance for use. A reasonable allowance for
use shall be fifteen cents for each mile the used motor vehicle
has been operated between its sale and the dealer's repurchase.
A
consumer shall have the option of retaining the use of any
vehicle returned under the provisions of this section until
such time as said consumer has been tendered a full refund.
The use of any vehicle retained by a consumer after its return
to a manufacturer under the provisions of this section, shall,
in instances in which a refund is tendered, be reflected
in the above-mentioned reasonable allowance for use.
A
used motor vehicle shall not be considered out of service
for purposes of the ten business-day period described hereinabove
for any day in which a part necessary to repair a defect
complained of is not in the dealer's possession; provided,
however, that the dealer has ordered the part by reasonable
means on the same day on which he knew or should have known
that the part was necessary, except that in no event shall
a part's unavailability operate to toll the ten business-day
period for more than twenty-one days. The applicable warranty
period shall be extended by the number of days a part is
unavailable.
-
All dealers shall submit to state-certified, used car arbitration,
if such arbitration is requested by the consumer, asserting
his or her right to a repurchase under this section, within
six months from the date of original delivery to such consumer
of a used motor vehicle. State-certified, used car arbitration
shall be performed by a professional arbitrator or arbitration
firm appointed by the secretary of consumer affairs and business
regulation and operating in accordance with the regulations
promulgated pursuant to this section, and shall result in
a written finding of whether the motor vehicle in dispute
meets the standards set forth by this section for vehicles
that are required to be repurchased. Said finding shall be
issued within forty-five days of receipt by said secretary
of a request by a consumer for state-certified arbitration
under this section. Said secretary shall promulgate rules
and regulations governing the proceedings of state-certified,
used car arbitration which shall promote their fairness and
efficiency. Such rules and regulations shall include, but
not be limited to, a requirement of the personal objectivity
of each such arbitrator, and the protection of the right
of each party to present its case and to be in attendance
during any presentation made by the other party.
If
a motor vehicle is found by state-certified, used car arbitration
to have met the standards set forth by this section for vehicles
required to be repurchased, and if the dealer who sold said
motor vehicle is found to have failed to provide said refund
as required, such dealer shall, within twenty-one days from
the issuance of such finding, deliver such refund, including
the incidental and other costs set forth in the definition
of "repurchase price" or appeal the finding in
a district or superior court. No such appeal by a dealer
shall be heard unless the petition for such appeal is filed
with the clerk of the district or superior court within twenty-one
days of issuance of the finding of the state-certified arbitration
and is accompanied by a bond in a principal sum equal to
the money award made by the state-certified arbitrator plus
five hundred dollars for anticipated attorneys' fees, secured
by cash or its equivalent, payable to the consumer.
The
liability of the surety of any bond filed pursuant to this
section shall be limited to the indemnification of the consumer
in the action. Such bond shall not limit or impair any right
of recovery otherwise available pursuant to law, nor shall
the amount of the bond be relevant in determining the amount
of recovery to which the consumer shall be entitled.
Upon
an appeal, the court shall vacate the award only if:
-
the award was procured by corruption, fraud or other undue
means;
-
there was evident partiality by an arbitrator or corruption
in any of the arbitrators, or misconduct prejudicing the
rights of any party; or
-
the arbitrators exceeded their powers.
In
addition to any other rights and remedies, any consumer dissatisfied
with any finding of state-certified, used car arbitration
shall have the right to file a claim pursuant to chapter
ninety-three A.
In
addition to any other recovery, any prevailing consumer shall
be awarded reasonable attorneys' fees and costs.
Whoever,
within twenty-one days of any finding in favor of the consumer
of the state-certified, used car arbitration, fails to appeal
such finding and does not deliver a refund shall be punished
by a fine of fifty dollars per day until the delivery of
such refund. Said fine shall not exceed five hundred dollars
for each such violation. The amount of said fine shall begin
to accumulate on the twenty-second day following the arbitration
decision. If eighty-one days has elapsed from the issuance
of a finding in favor of the consumer of the state-certified,
used car arbitration, and no appeal has been taken and no
award delivered and no fine paid, the attorney general shall
initiate proceedings against dealer for failure to pay said
fine. The proceedings initiated pursuant to the provisions
of this section shall be commenced in superior court department
of the trial court.
In
addition to the remedies hereinbefore provided, the attorney
general may bring an action on behalf of the commonwealth
to restrain further violation of this section, to enforce
any provision, and for such other relief as may be appropriate.
-
At any time within the applicable warranty period and after
a consumer has complained of a defect, notwithstanding any
objection from the consumer, the dealer shall have the option
of repurchasing a used vehicle and refunding the full repurchase
price, less a reasonable allowance for use. A reasonable
allowance for use shall be fifteen cents for each mile the
used motor vehicle had been operated between its sale and
the dealer's repurchase.
-
If the dealer is required to or elects to repurchase a vehicle
under the terms of this section, the consumer and dealer
shall cooperate with each other to execute all necessary
documents in order to clear the title of any encumbrances
on the repurchased vehicle.
-
It shall be an affirmative defense to any claim under this
section that an alleged defect
- does not impair the vehicle's
use or safety,
- is the result of owner negligence, abuse,
damage caused by accident, vandalism, or, an attempt to repair
the vehicle by a person other than the dealer, the dealer's
designee, or the manufacturer's representative under clause
(ii) of paragraph (A) of subsection (2),
- is the result
of any attempt by the consumer to modify the vehicle,
-
was covered or warranted under an express warranty issued
by the manufacturer of such used motor vehicle, that such
warranty issued by the manufacturer of such used motor vehicle
was in effect during the warranty period established by this
section, so long as the conditions in said clause (ii) of
said paragraph (A) of said subsection (2) are met.
-
Clear and conspicuous notice of the warranties created by
this section, of the rights pertaining thereto, and of the
implied warranty of merchantability shall be given to the
consumer in writing at the time the consumer purchases a
used motor vehicle from the dealer. Failure to provide such
notice shall toll the warranty periods under this section
until such notice is given.
-
The secretary of consumer affairs and business regulation
shall promulgate rules and regulations to implement the notice
provisions of this section. Said rules and regulations shall
include the establishment of wording, format, placement,
and distribution of all notices specified in this section.
In her discretion, and in order to facilitate ease of understanding
by consumers, said secretary may consolidate the notices
required by this section and any other notices pertaining
to the purchase of motor vehicles; provided, however, that
such consolidation does not render the notices inconsistent
with any of the provisions of this section or any other law.
Each notice required by this section shall describe the procedures
available to redress violations of this section and shall
contain the telephone number of the attorney general's consumer
protection division complaint section and the executive office
of consumer affairs and business regulation.
-
A dealer's failure to comply with any of the provisions of
this section shall constitute an unfair or deceptive act
under the provisions of chapter ninety-three A.
-
Notwithstanding any provisions of law to the contrary, this
section shall not apply to any used motor vehicle sold by
a dealer to a consumer for less than seven hundred dollars.
-
A private seller shall clearly disclose to any prospective
buyer, before the sale is completed, all defects the seller
knows of which impair the used motor vehicle's safety or
substantially impair its use. Failure to so disclose known
defects shall entitle the buyer, within thirty days after
the sale, to rescind the sale and be entitled to return of
all monies paid to the seller less a reasonable amount for
use as defined in clause (iv) of paragraph (A) subsection
(3). In any subsequent action by a buyer under this section,
if the court finds that the settlement offer was unreasonable
in light of the circumstances or that the private seller
has otherwise failed to comply with the requirements of this
subsection, in addition to damages, it shall award the buyer
reasonable attorneys' fees and costs; if the court finds
that the buyer's action was frivolous or not in good faith,
it shall award the seller reasonable attorneys' fees and
costs. It shall be an affirmative defense in any such action
that an alleged defect does not impair the vehicle's safety,
or substantially impair its use, or that it is the result
of the buyer's negligence, abuse, damage caused by accident,
vandalism or attempt to modify the vehicle.
-
Nothing in this section shall be construed in any way to
limit the enforceability of any implied warranties created
by law, any rights created by section seven N or seven N?,
or chapter ninety-three A or any rules and regulations promulgated
pursuant thereto, or express warranties given by a dealer
in connection with the sale of a used motor vehicle, or any
other rights or remedies available to consumers under applicable
law.
-
If a consumer is eligible for relief under the provisions
of section seven N?, to have repairs effected or other relief
provided under the provisions of an express warranty covering
such used motor vehicle issued by the manufacturer of such
used motor vehicle, said consumer shall make reasonable effort
in accordance with the terms and conditions thereof to obtain
such relief or repairs before seeking enforcement of rights
under this section. If the consumer, notwithstanding his
eligibility to do so, is unable to enforce rights under said
section seven N? or under such express warranty and the dealer
provides such relief or, in accordance with the provisions
of this section, repurchases such used motor vehicle, the
dealer shall be subrogated to the rights of such consumer
against such manufacturer under the provisions of said section
seven N?, such express warranty and otherwise in accordance
with applicable law, and may enforce the same in his name
in the superior court or district court department. Such
manufacturer shall hold the dealer harmless from and against
all damages, liabilities, losses and reasonable expenses
of suit, including reasonable attorneys' fees arising out
of or incurred by the dealer by its compliance with the provisions
of this section if such manufacturer, having been notified
in writing by the dealer that such rights have been asserted
by a consumer, fails to resolve the same at its own expense
in or within seven business days.
-
The licensing authorities responsible pursuant to section
fifty-nine of chapter one hundred and forty for licensing
used motor vehicle dealers shall distribute copies of this
section to each dealer licensed at any time a license is
granted or renewed.
-
The provisions of this section shall not apply to the sale
of a leased vehicle by a lessor to the lessee of said vehicle,
a family member or employee of said lessee or to the sale
of a used motor vehicle by an employer to his employee.
-
Any action brought pursuant to this section shall be commenced
within two years of the date of original delivery of the
used motor vehicle to the consumer. (Added by 1987, 289,
Sec. 1.)
Chapter
90: Section 7N?.
Defective or malfunctioning new motor vehicles;
sale and repair or replacement.
Section
7N?.
- For purposes of this section the following terms
shall have the following meanings:
"Business
day", any day during which the service departments of
authorized dealers of the manufacturer of the motor vehicle
are normally open for business.
"Consumer",
a buyer or lessee, other than for purposes of resale, of
a motor vehicle, any person to whom such motor vehicle is
transferred during the duration of any express or implied
warranty applicable to such motor vehicle, and any other
person entitled by the terms of such warranty to enforce
its obligations.
"Dealer",
any class one seller of motor vehicles as defined in section
fifty-eight of chapter one hundred and forty.
"Lessee",
any person who acquires the right to possession of and use
of a motor vehicle under a lease agreement for a term of
not less than one year.
"Manufacturer",
any person who is engaged in the business of manufacturing
motor vehicles, or, in the case of motor vehicles not manufactured
in the United States, any person who is engaged in the business
of importing motor vehicles.
"Motor
vehicle" or "vehicle", any motor vehicle as
defined in section one sold, leased or replaced by a dealer
or manufacturer after the effective date of this section,
except that it shall not include auto homes, vehicles built
primarily for off-road use or any vehicle used primarily
for business purposes.
"Nonconformity",
any specific or generic defect or malfunction, or any concurrent
combination of such defects or malfunctions that substantially
impairs the use, market value or safety of a motor vehicle.
"Term
of protection", one year or fifteen thousand miles of
use from the date of original delivery of a new motor vehicle,
whichever comes first; or, in the case of a replacement vehicle
provided by a manufacturer to a consumer under this section,
one year or fifteen thousand miles from the date of delivery
to the consumer of said replacement vehicle, whichever comes
first.
-
If a motor vehicle does not conform to any applicable express
or implied warranty, and the consumer reports the nonconformity
to the manufacturer of the vehicle, its agent or its authorized
dealer during the term of protection, the manufacturer, its
agent or its authorized dealer shall effect such repairs
as are necessary to conform the vehicle to such warranty.
If
the manufacturer, its agent or authorized dealer does not
conform the motor vehicle to any such applicable express
or implied warranty by curing any nonconformity after a reasonable
number of attempts, the manufacturer shall accept return
of the vehicle from the consumer. In instances in which a
vehicle is sold and subsequently returned, the manufacturer
shall refund the full contract price of the vehicle including
all credits and allowances for any trade-in vehicle, less
any cash award that was made by the manufacturer in an attempt
to resolve the dispute and was accepted by the consumer,
and a reasonable allowance for use, or shall offer to replace
the vehicle. In instances in which a vehicle is leased and
subsequently returned, the manufacturer shall refund all
payments made by the consumer to the manufacturer under the
terms of the lease agreement less any cash award that was
made by the manufacturer in an attempt to resolve the dispute
and was accepted by the consumer, and a reasonable allowance
for use, or shall offer to replace the vehicle. The consumer
shall have an unqualified right to reject a manufacturer's
offer of replacement and demand a refund. In instances in
which a vehicle is replaced by a manufacturer under the provisions
of this section, said manufacturer shall reimburse the consumer
for any fees for the transfer of registration or any sales
tax incurred by the consumer as a result of such replacement.
In instances in which a leased vehicle is replaced by a manufacturer
under the terms of this section, an identical model vehicle
shall be provided to the consumer for the remaining term
of the original lease agreement. In instances in which a
vehicle which was financed by the manufacturer or its subsidiary
or agent is replaced under the provisions of this section,
said manufacturer, subsidiary or agent shall not require
the consumer to enter into any refinancing agreement which
would create any financial obligations upon such consumer
beyond those implied by the original financing agreement.
In instances in which a vehicle which was leased from a dealer
or manufacturer is replaced under the provisions of this
section, said dealer or manufacturer shall not require the
consumer to enter into any lease agreement which would create
any financial obligations upon such consumer beyond those
implied by the original lease agreement. In instances in
which a refund is tendered under the provisions of this section,
the manufacturer shall also reimburse the consumer for incidental
costs including sales tax, registration fee, finance charges
and any cost of options added by an authorized dealer. Whenever
a vehicle is replaced a refund is given under the provisions
of this section, in instances in which towing services and
rental vehicles were not made available at no cost to the
consumer, the manufacturer shall also reimburse the consumer
for towing and reasonable rental costs that were a direct
result of vehicle nonconformity. Refunds shall be made to
the consumer and lienholder, if any, as their interests may
appear. A reasonable allowance for use for all motor vehicles
other than motorcycles shall be obtained by multiplying the
total contract price of the vehicle, or in the case of a
leased vehicle the total amount of payments made by the consumer
to the manufacturer under the terms of the lease agreement,
by a fraction having as its denominator one hundred thousand
and having as its numerator the number of miles that vehicle
traveled prior to the manufacturer's acceptance of its return.
A reasonable allowance for use for motorcycles shall be obtained
by multiplying the total contract price of the motorcycle
by a fraction having as its denominator twenty-five thousand
and having as its numerator the number of miles that the
vehicle traveled prior to the manufacturer's acceptance of
its return.
It
shall be an affirmative defense to any claim under this section:
- that an alleged nonconformity does not substantially
impair the use, market value or safety of the vehicle;
-
that a nonconformity is the result of owner negligence, damage
caused by accident, vandalism, or attempt to repair the vehicle
by a person other than the manufacturer, its agent or authorized
dealer; or
- that a nonconformity is the result of any
attempt substantially to modify the vehicle which was not
authorized by the manufacturer.
A
consumer shall have the option of retaining the use of any
vehicle returned under the provisions of this section until
such time as said consumer has been tendered a full refund
or a replacement that is acceptable to the consumer. The
use of any vehicle retained by a consumer after its return
to a manufacturer under the provisions of this section, shall,
in instances in which a refund is tendered, be reflected
in the above mentioned reasonable allowance for use.
-
A reasonable number of attempts shall be deemed to have been
undertaken to conform a motor vehicle to any applicable express
or implied warranties if
- the same nonconformity has
been subject to repair three or more times by the manufacturer
or its agents or authorized dealers within the term of protection,
but such nonconformity continues to exist or such nonconformity
has recurred within the term of protection, or
- the
vehicle is out of service by reason of repair of any nonconformity
for a cumulative total of fifteen or more business days during
the term of protection; provided, however, that the manufacturer
shall be afforded one additional opportunity, not to exceed
seven business days, to cure any nonconformity arising during
the term of protection, notwithstanding the fact that such
additional opportunity to cure commences after the term of
protection.
Such additional opportunity to cure shall commence
on the day the manufacturer first knows or should have known
that the limits specified in clause (a) or (b) have been
met or exceeded. The term of protection, said fifteen business
day period and said additional opportunity to cure shall
be extended by any period of time during which repair services
are not available to the consumer as a direct result of a
war, invasion, fire, flood or other natural disaster. The
term of protection, said fifteen business day period and
said additional opportunity to cure shall also be extended
by that period of time during which repair services are not
available as a direct result of a strike; provided, however,
that the manufacturer, its agent, or authorized dealer provides
or makes provision for the free use of a vehicle to any consumer
whose vehicle is out of service by reason of repair during
a strike. The burden shall be on the manufacturer to show
that any event claimed as a reason for an extension under
the provisions of this paragraph was the direct cause for
the failure of the manufacturer, its agent or authorized
dealer to cure any nonconformity during the time of said
event. Extensions for concurrent events shall not be cumulative.
-
Nothing in this section shall be construed as imposing any
liability on an authorized dealer or creating any cause of
action by a consumer against a dealer under the provisions
of this section.
Nothing
in this section shall be construed to limit the rights or
remedies which are otherwise available to a consumer or manufacturer
under any other applicable provision of law.
Nothing
in this section shall be construed as imposing any liability
on a dealer or creating a cause of action by a manufacturer
against its authorized dealer under this section except with
respect to
- failure by an authorized dealer to properly
effect preparation, installation of options or repairs when
such preparation, installation of options or repairs would
have prevented the occurrence of or cured a nonconformity;
- express warranties offered by an authorized dealer which
exceed the provisions of the manufacturer's express warranties;
and
- that portion of the cost of reimbursing a consumer
for dealer-added options which represents the dealer profit
from the addition of such options. The manufacturer shall
reimburse its authorized dealer for all incidental and consequential
damages, including attorney's fees, incurred by such dealer
as a direct result of any legal action brought by a consumer
under this section.
No
consumer shall be required by any manufacturer, its agent
or its authorized dealer to give notice directly to a manufacturer
of the existence of any nonconformity before resorting to
state-certified, new car arbitration.
No
motor vehicle that is returned to the manufacturer under
the provisions of this section shall be resold in the commonwealth
without clear and conspicuous written disclosure of the fact
that it was so returned prior to resale of the vehicle. The
attorney general shall prescribe the exact form and content
of any such disclosure statement.
-
All manufacturers shall submit to state-certified, new car
arbitration, if such arbitration is requested by the consumer
within eighteen months from the date of original delivery
to such consumer of a new motor vehicle. State-certified,
new car arbitration shall be performed by a professional
arbitrator or arbitration firm appointed by the secretary
of consumer affairs and business regulation and operating
in accordance with the regulations promulgated pursuant to
this section, and shall result in a written finding of whether
the motor vehicle in dispute meets the standards set forth
by this section for vehicles that are required to be replaced
or refunded. Said finding shall be issued within forty-five
days of receipt by said secretary of a request by a consumer
for state-certified arbitration under this section. Said
secretary shall promulgate rules and regulations governing
the proceedings of state-certified, new car arbitration which
shall promote their fairness and efficiency. Such rules and
regulations shall include, but not be limited to, a requirement
of the personal objectivity of each arbitrator in the results
of the dispute he will hear, and the protection of the right
of each party to present its case and to be in attendance
during any presentation made by the other party. All findings
of fact issuing from a state-certified, new car arbitration
shall be taken as prima facie evidence of whether the standards
set forth in this section for vehicles required to be refunded
or replaced have been met in any subsequent action brought
by either party ensuing from the matter considered in said
arbitration.
If
a motor vehicle is found by state-certified, new car arbitration
to have met the standards set forth by this section for vehicles
required to be replaced or refunded, and if the manufacturer
of said motor vehicle is found to have failed to provide
said refund or replacement as required, such manufacturer
shall, within twenty-one days from the issuance of such finding,
deliver such refund or replacement, including the incidental
and other costs set forth in subsection (3), or appeal the
finding in superior court. No appeal by a manufacturer shall
be heard unless the petition for such appeal is filed with
the clerk of the superior court within twenty-one days of
issuance of the finding of the state-certified arbitration
and is accompanied by a bond in a principal sum equal to
the money award made by the state-certified arbitrator plus
two thousand five hundred dollars for anticipated attorneys'
fees, secured by cash or its equivalent, payable to the consumer.
The
liability of the surety of any bond filed pursuant to this
section shall be limited to the indemnification of the consumer
in the action. Such bond shall not limit or impair any right
of recovery otherwise available pursuant to law, nor shall
the amount of the bond be relevant in determining the amount
of recovery to which the consumer shall be entitled. In the
event that any state-certified arbitration, resulting in
an award of a refund or replacement, is upheld by the court,
recovery by the consumer shall include continuing damages
in the amount of twenty-five dollars per day for each day,
subsequent to the day the motor vehicle was returned to the
manufacturer pursuant to subsection three, that said vehicle
was out of use as a direct result of any nonconformity not
issuing from owner negligence, accident, vandalism, or any
attempt to repair or substantially modify the vehicle by
a person other than the manufacturer, its agent or authorized
dealer; provided, however, that the manufacturer did not
make a comparable vehicle available to the consumer free
of charge. In addition to any other recovery, any prevailing
consumer shall be awarded reasonable attorneys' fees and
costs. If the court finds that the manufacturer did not have
any reasonable basis for its appeal or that the appeal was
frivolous, the court shall double the amount of the total
award made to the consumer. Any consumer dissatisfied with
any finding of state-certified, new car arbitration shall
have the right to file a claim pursuant to chapter ninety-three
A.
(6A)
A clear and conspicuous listing of the rights of the consumer
under this section shall be affixed by a sticker to a window
of each new motor vehicle offered for sale or lease in the
commonwealth. An enumeration of these rights shall also be
provided along with ownership manual materials. The form
and manner of these notices shall be prescribed by the secretary
of consumer affairs and business regulations.
-
Failure to comply with any of the provisions of this section
shall constitute an unfair or deceptive act under the provisions
of chapter ninety-three A. The failure of a manufacturer
either to abide by the decision of a state-certified arbitration
or to file a timely appeal shall entitle any prevailing consumer
to an award of no less than two times the actual damages,
unless said manufacturer can prove that such failure was
beyond his control. For the purposes of said chapter ninety-three
A, the timely delivery by a manufacturer of a refund or acceptable
replacement, pursuant to a finding by state-certified arbitration,
shall constitute the granting of relief upon demand.
The
secretary of consumer affairs and business regulation shall
inform the office of the attorney general of any method,
act or practice of which she is aware that is deemed by her
to be a violation of any provision of this section.
-
Whoever, within twenty-one days of any finding in favor of
the consumer of the state-certified, new car arbitration,
fails to appeal such finding and does not deliver a refund
or replacement vehicle or notify the consumer of the estimated
delivery date of the replacement vehicle, shall be punished
by a fine of five thousand dollars per day until the delivery
of such refund or replacement. The estimated delivery date
shall not exceed sixty days from the date the manufacturer
notifies the consumer that a delivery will be made. Said
fine shall not exceed fifty thousand dollars for each such
violation. The amount of said fine shall begin to accumulate
on the twenty-second day following the arbitration decision.
If eighty-one days has elapsed from the issuance of a finding
in favor of the consumer of the state-certified, new car
arbitration and no appeal has been taken and no award delivered
and no fine paid, the attorney general shall initiate proceedings
against said manufacturer for failure to pay said fine. The
proceedings initiated pursuant to the provisions of this
section shall be commenced in superior court department of
the trial court.
In
addition to the remedies hereinbefore provided, the attorney
general may bring an action on behalf of the commonwealth
to restrain further violation of this section, to enforce
any provision, and for such other relief as may be appropriate.
|
|
The
Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act
The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act is a Federal Law that protects the buyer of any product which costs more than $25 and comes with an express written warranty.
This law applies to any product that you buy that does not perform as it should.
Your car is a major investment, rationalized by the peace of mind that flows from its expected dependability and safety. Accordingly, you are entitled
to expect an automobile properly constructed and regulated to provide reasonably safe, trouble-free, and dependable transportation – regardless
of the exact make and model you bought. Unfortunately, sometimes these principles do not hold true and defects arise in automobiles. Although one defect
is not actionable, repeated defects are as there exists a generally accepted rule that unsuccessful repair efforts render the warrantor liable. Simply
put, there comes a time when “enough is enough” – when after having to take your car into the shop for repairs an inordinate number
of times and experiencing all of the attendant inconvenience, you are entitled to say, ‘That’s all,’ and revoke, notwithstanding the
seller’s repeated good faith efforts to fix the car. The rationale behind these basic principles is clear: once your faith in the vehicle is shaken,
the vehicle loses its real value to you and becomes an instrument whose integrity is impaired and whose operation is fraught with apprehension. The question
thus becomes when is “enough”?
As you know, enough is never enough from your warrantor’s point of view and you should simply continue to have your defective vehicle repaired – time
and time again. However, you are not required to allow a warrantor to tinker with your vehicle indefinitely in the hope that it may eventually be fixed.
Rather, you are entitled to expect your vehicle to be repaired within a reasonable opportunity. To this end, both the federal Moss Warranty Act, and
the various state “lemon laws,” require repairs to your vehicle be performed within a reasonable opportunity.
Under the Magnuson-Moss Warranty
Act, a warrantor should perform adequate repairs in at least two, and possibly three, attempts to correct a particular defect. Further, the Magnuson-Moss
Warranty Act’s reasonableness requirement applies to your vehicle as a whole rather than to each individual defect
that arises. Although most of the Lemon Laws vary from state to state, each individual law usually require a warrantor to cure a specific defect within
four to five attempts or the automobile as a whole within thirty days. If the warrantor fails to meet this obligation, most of the lemon laws provide
for a full refund or new replacement vehicle. Further, this reasonable number of attempts/reasonable opportunity standard, whether it be that of the
Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act or that of the Lemon Laws, is akin to strict liability – once this threshold has been met, the continued existence of
a defect is irrelevant and you are still entitled to relief.
One of the most important parts of the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act is its fee shifting
provision. This provision provides that you may recover the attorney fees incurred in the prosecution of your case if you are successful – independent
of how much you actually win. That rational behind this fee shifting provision is to twofold: (1) to ensure you will be able to vindicate your rights
without having to expend large sums on attorney's fees and (2) because automobile manufacturers are able to write off all expenses of defense as a
legitimate business expense, whereas you, the average consumer, obviously does not have that kind of economic staying power. Most of the Lemon Laws contain
similar fee shifting provisions.
You may also derive additional warranty rights from the Uniform Commercial Code; however, the Code does not allow you
in most states to recover your attorney fees and is also not as consumer friendly as the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act or the various state lemon laws.
The narrative information on Magnuson-Moss, UCC and lemon laws on these pages is provided by Marshall Meyers, attorney.
|
|
Uniform
Commercial Code Summary
The Uniform Commercial Code or UCC has been enacted in all 50 states and some of the territories of the United States. It is the primary source of law
in all contracts dealing with the sale of products. The TARR refers to Tender, Acceptance, Rejection, Revocation and applies to different aspects of
the consumer's "relationship" with the purchased goods.
TENDER -
The tender provisions of the Uniform Commercial Code contained in Section2-601 provide that the buyer is entitled to reject any goods that fail in
any respect to conform to the contract. Unfortunately, new cars are often technically complex and their innermost workings are beyond the understanding
of the average new car buyer. The buyer, therefore, does not know whether the goods are then conforming.
ACCEPTANCE -
The new car buyer accepts the goods believing and expecting that the manufacturer will repair any problem he has with the goods under the warranty.
REJECTION
-
The new car buyer may discover a problem with the vehicle within the first few miles of his purchase. This would allow the new car buyer to reject
the goods. If the new car buyer discovers a defect in the car within a reasonable time to inspect the vehicle, he may reject the vehicle. This period
is not defined. On the one hand, the buyer must be given a reasonable time to inspect and that reasonable time to inspect will be held as an acceptance
of the vehicle. The Courts will decide this reasonable time to inspect based on the knowledge and experience of the buyer, the difficulty in discovering
the defect, and the opportunity to discover the defect.
The following is an example of a case of rejection: Mr. Zabriskie purchase a new 1966 Chevrolet Biscayne. After picking up the car on Friday evening,
while en route to his home 2.5 miles away, and within 7/10ths of a mile from the dealership, the car stalled and stalled again within 15 feet. Thereafter,
the car would only drive in low gear. The buyer rejected the vehicle and stopped payment on his check. The dealer contended that the buyer could not
reject the car because he had driven it around the block and that was his reasonable opportunity to inspect. The New Jersey Court said;
To the layman,
the complicated mechanisms of today's automobile are a complete mystery. To have the automobile inspected by someone with sufficient expertise to disassemble
the vehicle in order the discover latent defects before the contract is signed, is assuredly impossible and highly impractical. Consequently, the first
few miles of driving become even more significant to the excited new car buyer. This is the buyer's first reasonable opportunity to enjoy his new vehicle
to see if it conforms to what it was represented to be and whether he is getting what he bargained for. How long the buyer may drive the new car under
the guise of inspection of new goods is not an issue in the present case because 7/10th of a mile is clearly within the ambit of a reasonable opportunity
to inspect. Zabriskie Chevrolet, Inc. v. Smith, 240 A. 2d 195(1968)
It is suggested that Courts will tend to excuse use by consumers if possible.
REVOCATION -
What happens when the consumer has used the new car for a lengthy period of time? This is the typical lemon car case. The UCC provides that a buyer
may revoke his acceptance of goods whose non-conformity substantially impairs the value of the goods to him when he has accepted the goods without
discovery of a non-conformity because it was difficult to discover or if he was assured that non-conformities would be repaired. Of course, the average
new car buyer does not learn of the nonconformity until hundreds of thousands of miles later. And because quality is job one, and manufacturers are
competing on the basis of their warranties, the consumer always is assured that any noncomformities he does discover will be remedied.
What is a noncomformity substantially impairing the value of the vehicle?
- A noncomformity may include a number of relatively minor defects whose cumulative total adds up to a substantial impairment. This is the "Shake
Faith" Doctrine first stated in the Zabrisikie case. "For a majority of people the purchase of a new car is a major investment, rationalized
by the peace of mind that flows from its dependability and safety. Once their faith is shaken, the vehicle loses not only its real value in their eyes,
but becomes an instrument whose integrity is substantially impaired and whose operation is fraught with apprehension".
- A substantial noncomformity may include a failure or refusal to repair the goods under the warranty. In Durfee V. Rod Baxter Imports, the Minnesota
Court held that the Saab owner that was plagued by a series of of annoying minor defects and stalling, which were never repaired after a number of attempts,
could revoke, "if repairs are not successfully undertaken within a reasonable time", the consumer may elect to revoke.
- Substantial Non Conformity and Lemon Laws often define what may be considered a substantial impairment. These definitions have been successfully used
to flesh out the substantial impairment in the UCC.
Additional narrative information on Magnusson-Moss, UCC and lemon laws on these pages is provided by T. Michael Flinn, attorney.
|
|
|
|
 |